| Name | Team | NAHL Team(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Adam Baughman | Harvard | Topeka |
| Evan Cowley | Denver | Wichita Falls |
| Nick Deery | Minnesota Duluth | Odessa Brookings |
| Billy Exell | Minnesota Duluth | Minnesota |
| Erich Fear | Denver | Springfield |
| Jake Horton | Harvard | Janesville |
| Evan Janssen | Denver | Alaska |
| Peter Krieger | Minnesota Duluth | Aberdeen |
| Nathan Krusko | Harvard | Minnesota |
| Merrick Madsen | Harvard | Minot |
| Jade Miller | Minnesota Duluth | Austin |
| Luke Ripley | Notre Dame | Dawson Creek |
| Evan Ritt | Denver | Jamestown |
| Emil Romig | Denver | Corpus Christi |
| Hunter Shepard | Minnesota Duluth | Bismarck |
| Colin Staub | Denver | Wichita Falls |
Minnesota Duluth’s Billy Exell won the NAHL Robertson Cup, significant of the league’s playoff champion, with the Minnesota Wilderness while Notre Dame’s Luke Novak helped the Jersey Hitmen claim the 2016 USPHL Dineen Cup, significant of the league’s playoff champion.