| Player | Frozen Four Team | NAHL TEAM(S) |
|---|---|---|
| Ben Almquist | Minnesota Duluth | Austin |
| Koby Bender | Minnesota Duluth | Minnesota Wilderness |
| Aaron Bohlinger | Massachusetts | Philadelphia |
| Cade Borchardt | Minnesota State | Brookings |
| Chase Brand | St. Cloud State | Brookings |
| Todd Burgess#* | Minnesota State | Fairbanks |
| Andy Carroll | Minnesota State | Aberdeen |
| Jaxon Castor^ | St. Cloud State | Shreveport |
| Seamus Donohue | St. Cloud State | Wichita Falls |
| Tanner Edwards | Minnesota State | Fairbanks |
| Colin Felix | Massachusetts | Janesville |
| Kevin Fitzgerald | St. Cloud State | Topeka & Aberdeen |
| Brendan Furry | Minnesota State | Amarillo |
| Dallas Gerads | Minnesota State | Rio Grande Valley |
| Darian Gotz | Minnesota Duluth | Minnesota Wilderness |
| Henry Graham | Massachusetts | Springfield |
| Will Hammer | St. Cloud State | Aberdeen & Minnesota Magicians |
| Jack Johnston | St. Cloud State | Fairbanks |
| Cole Koepke | Minnesota Duluth | Minnesota Wilderness |
| Jarrett Lee | Minnesota Duluth | Minnesota Magicians |
| Hunter Lellig | Minnesota Duluth | Minnesota Magicians |
| Reggie Lutz* | Minnesota Duluth | Fairbanks |
| Oliver MacDonald | Massachusetts | New Jersey |
| Dryden McKay | Minnesota State | Springfield & Corpus Christi |
| Shane McMahan | Minnesota State | Aston |
| Spencer Meier | St. Cloud State | Minot |
| George Mika | Massachusetts | Amarillo |
| Joe Molenaar | St. Cloud State | Aberdeen |
| Thomas Rocco | St. Cloud State | Aberdeen |
| Louie Roehl | Minnesota Duluth | Minnesota Wilderness |
| Jake Rosenbaum | Minnesota Duluth | Wilkes-Barre/Scranton, Amarillo, Topeka & Minot |
| Kobe Roth | Minnesota Duluth | Minnesota Wilderness |
| Nathan Smith | Minnesota State | Aberdeen |
| Jared Spooner | Minnesota State | Bismarck |
| Zach Stejskal | Minnesota Duluth | Wilkes-Barre/Scranton |
| Kolby Vegara | Massachusetts | Aston & Philadelphia |
| Trevor Zins | St. Cloud State | Topeka |
| Riese Zmolek | Minnesota State | Austin |
# - 2014 Robertson Cup Champion
* - 2016 Robertson Cup Champion
^ - 2018 Robertson Cup Champion